Does innovation drive capitalism, or does capitalism fuel innovation? This conundrum has long intrigued economists, business leaders, and policymakers. Are these two forces mutually dependent, or does one inherently lead to the success of the other? While these questions are global in nature, their implications are particularly pertinent to India, where innovation and capital appear to coexist in a tenuous and complex relationship.
Innovation without capital is akin to a spark without fuel; it cannot sustain itself. Similarly, capital without innovation is often stagnant, failing to deliver the yields and growth expected in modern economies. This symbiosis is evident when contrasting India’s economic trajectory with that of the United States.
The US economy thrives on a relentless commitment to innovation. Startups and established firms succeed or fail based on their ability to innovate, adapt, and scale. In contrast, India’s economic landscape often revolves around traditional rent-seeking behaviours — acquiring assets or privileges that guarantee returns, such as land, resources, or government contracts. As a result, the role of innovation in India’s capitalism is more subdued, raising critical questions about the country’s ability to leverage its vast talent pool and entrepreneurial spirit.
During a recent meeting showcasing new product launches touted as “innovative,” it became evident that many of these so-called breakthroughs were merely repackaged ideas from decades past. While the branding and marketing strategies have evolved, the underlying delivery methods remain the same. This highlights a recurring issue in India: innovation is often superficial and fails to disrupt or fundamentally redefine industries.
For example, consider the rise of Indian startups like Byju’s. While the company has achieved significant scale through aggressive capital deployment, it is debatable whether its offerings qualify as true innovation. Critics argue that such companies leverage existing frameworks rather than pioneer groundbreaking solutions. This approach underscores a broader trend where Indian enterprises often prioritise scalability and profitability over genuine intellectual advancements.
Intellectual property (IP) recognition and protection are critical enablers of innovation. Unfortunately, India’s history and industrial practices have fostered a culture that often undervalues IP. The pharmaceutical industry, for instance, has long thrived on producing generic versions of patented drugs, which has led to the perception that IP is negotiable rather than sacrosanct.
“Innovation thrives in environments where intellectual property is respected,” says Peter Thiel, co-founder of PayPal and an outspoken advocate for disruptive innovation. “Without IP protection, there is little incentive to invest in research and development.” This lack of respect for IP stifles the willingness of Indian entrepreneurs to invest in cutting-edge technologies, further hampering the country’s innovation potential.
Another key factor linking innovation and capital is the role of venture capital (VC). In the U.S., VCs actively seek disruptive technologies and invest heavily in their development. However, even when startups secure VC funding in India, they often struggle to establish a presence abroad, particularly in the U.S., to scale effectively. “The moment a startup shows potential in India, its investors insist on setting up a base in Silicon Valley,” observes Raghuram Rajan, former Governor of the Reserve Bank of India. “This brain drain not only limits India’s ability to retain its best talent but also hampers the development of a robust local ecosystem for innovation.”
India’s economic challenges—from unemployment to income inequality—underscore the urgent need for innovation. Unlike traditional industries, innovation-driven sectors such as technology, biotech, and renewable energy have the potential to create high-value jobs, attract foreign investment, and drive sustainable growth.
However, for innovation to thrive, India must address systemic barriers. This includes investing in quality education, fostering a risk-taking culture, and strengthening legal frameworks for intellectual property protection. As Nobel laureate Paul Romer notes, “Economic growth springs from better recipes, not just more cooking. Better recipes mean more innovation.”
Innovation cannot be mandated; it must be nurtured. This requires a shift in mindset from risk aversion to experimentation. Government initiatives like “Startup India” and “Digital India” are steps in the right direction, but their implementation must focus on building long-term capabilities rather than short-term gains.
India’s investment in research and development as a percentage of GDP remains among the lowest in the world. Increasing this investment is critical to driving innovation in the healthcare, agriculture, and clean energy sectors.
Robust intellectual property laws and enforcement mechanisms are essential to incentivise innovation. This includes protecting patents and educating businesses and individuals about the value of IP.
India must create an environment where its brightest minds can thrive domestically. This includes addressing bureaucratic hurdles, improving infrastructure, and incentivising startups to remain rooted in India.
Does innovation drive capitalism, or does capitalism enable innovation? The relationship between these forces in India remains underdeveloped yet full of potential. By addressing cultural, structural, and policy barriers, India can transform its economy into one fuelled by innovation rather than depending on traditional rent-seeking models. “The best way to predict the future is to invent it,” said Alan Kay, a pioneer in computer science. For India, the challenge is not merely to predict its economic future but to actively shape it through a commitment to innovation and the intelligent deployment of capital. Only then can the country realise its full potential on the global stage.
Steve Correa is an Executive Coach and Author of The Indian Boss at Work, Thinking Global, Acting Indian
Ronald D’Souza has Corporate and Consulting Experience and mentors new startups.
This article was published on Medium on 18th Nov 2024 https://medium.com/@stevecorrea.com/innovation-capitalism-and-the-economic-dilemma-in-india-steve-correa-and-ronald-dsouza-4bff3699eac5
Share this post